No menu items!

COSTA RICA'S LEADING ENGLISH LANGUAGE NEWSPAPER

HomeNewsBahía Papagayo Project Clears Hurdle as Court Rejects Environmental Appeal

Bahía Papagayo Project Clears Hurdle as Court Rejects Environmental Appeal

A $925 million tourism development in Guanacaste is pushing forward after Costa Rica’s Constitutional Court dismissed an appeal challenging its environmental approval. The Bahía Papagayo project, set to bring hotels and jobs to Playa Panamá, has sparked debate over balancing economic growth with environmental protection.

Court Rejects Appeal

Activist Gad Amit Kaufman, representing the Asociación Confraternidad Guanacasteca, filed the appeal to halt the project, arguing that the National Environmental Technical Secretariat (Setena) failed to properly consult the public. Kaufman cited a developer’s survey showing 88% of locals were unaware of the project, claiming it broke environmental rules.

On May 31, 2025, the Constitutional Court (Sala IV) rejected the appeal under resolution 2025-016284. The justices found that Setena followed the law by publishing the Environmental Impact Assessment in a national newspaper, with no public objections or requests for a hearing. They ruled that questioning the consultation’s quality is for regular courts, not constitutional ones.

A Bahía Papagayo spokesperson said, “This ruling confirms our commitment to a tourism model that’s responsible and boosts Guanacaste. We’ve followed all legal and environmental rules from the start.”

Led by ENJOY HOTELS & RESORTS S.A., the project covers 117 hectares and includes hotels, homes, and recreational areas. Developers pitch it as a low-impact tourism hub aligned with the Costa Rican Tourism Institute’s Master Plan and Setena’s guidelines, promising 1,200 direct jobs and better local infrastructure.

Environmental Risks vs. Economic Gains

Environmentalists warn the project threatens mature forests, wetlands, and a mangrove swamp, home to monkeys, raccoons, and coatis. “It risks cutting off wildlife corridors and destabilizing the coast,” Kaufman said. The Papagayo region also faces natural ocean acidification from seasonal upwelling, which could worsen reef damage if ecosystems are disrupted.

The ruling reflects Costa Rica’s challenge to balance growth with its eco-friendly reputation. A 2023 Samara project was scrapped after community pushback exposed weak approvals, and Kaufman’s appeal aimed for a similar outcome, but the court held firm.Locals are split—some welcome the jobs, others fear environmental damage and rising costs.

Developers emphasize transparency and coordination with authorities, arguing the project will strengthen Guanacaste’s tourism draw. But critics say the environmental cost could outweigh the benefits, especially if mangroves or forests are harmed. Kaufman may challenge the consultation process in ordinary courts, keeping the fight alive. Stay Tuned!

Trending Now

Illegal Airstrip Allegedly Built in Costa Rica’s Gandoca-Manzanillo Refuge

The Limón branch of the Environmental Prosecutor's Office is investigating the alleged construction of an airstrip inside the Gandoca-Manzanillo National Wildlife Refuge, as well...

Honduras Mayor Murdered in Motel Ambush Stirs Outrage

Francisco Martínez Domínguez, the mayor of San Isidro, a small municipality in Honduras, was brutally killed in Siguatepeque, about 90 km north of Tegucigalpa....

US and Panama Begin Joint Exercises to Protect Panama Canal

US forces teamed up with Panamanian police for fresh military drills focused on safeguarding the Panama Canal, starting amid ongoing debates about foreign influence...

Vigilante Justice in Quake-Hit Guatemala Town Claims Five Lives

In a Guatemalan town reeling from recent earthquakes, residents took matters into their own hands on Thursday night, lynching five men they accused of...

Canadian Tourism to Costa Rica Drops Amid Rising Crime Concerns

Canadian visits to Costa Rica have started to drop in 2025, with crime playing a big part in the shift. Data from the Costa...

El Salvador Under Fire for Detaining Migrants Without Rights or Access

Cardinal Gregorio Rosa Chávez on Wednesday urged the government of Nayib Bukele to provide information about the 252 Venezuelan migrants deported from the United...
spot_img
Costa Rica Tours
Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Travel Insurance
Costa Rica Rocking Chait
Costa Rica Travel

Latest News from Costa Rica