No menu items!

COSTA RICA'S LEADING ENGLISH LANGUAGE NEWSPAPER

HomeTopicsHealthCosta Rica IVF decree loses support of public health care system

Costa Rica IVF decree loses support of public health care system

President Luis Guillermo Solís’ decree legalizing in vitro fertilization in Costa Rica is going before the Supreme Court without the support of two major government agencies. The Government Attorney’s Office and the Costa Rican Social Security System both presented reports this week to the Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court — known as Sala IV — calling the decree unconstitutional.

The Government Attorney’s report said that the decree violates principles of separation of powers, the autonomy of the CCSS, and due process, among others. María del Rocío Sáenz, president of the Social Security System, or Caja, as it is known, said that the fertility treatment should only be regulated in Costa Rica by law, not executive decree.

Casa Presidencial presented its own report to Sala IV Wednesday defending the decree.

President Luis Guillermo Solís signed a decree on Sept. 11 regulating IVF in Costa Rica after a prolonged legal battle over the fertility practice. The battle was set off by a ruling from Sala IV in 2000 declaring that IVF violates the right to life guaranteed in the Costa Rican Constitution because fertilized eggs are sometimes discarded in the process.

The Inter-American Court of Human Rights ruled in 2012 that Costa Rica — which is a signatory to and host of the IACHR — must offer the practice after several couples successfully sued for the right to undergo IVF.

The Sala IV suspended the Solís administration’s decree on Oct. 7 in response to several constitutional challenges filed against it.

Casa Presidencial counsel Marvin Carvajal told The Tico Times he thought the Government Attorney’s Office and the Caja had misinterpreted the basis of the Inter-American Court’s ruling. He said that the matter is not one for legislative debate, and emphasized that the decree did not limit the rights of any Costa Rican citizen.

“When it comes to the ruling of an international court, like the Inter-American Court, it’s not for us to question or argue if the ruling was good or bad. The only thing we need to do is comply with it,” Carvajal said.

Despite losing the support of the Caja and Government Attorney’s Office, Carvajal said that Casa Presidencial remained optimistic about its case. He said that the court would hear new evidence, including what he argued was a more robust regulation than before the 2000 ban, and advancements in the science behind the fertility technique.

The lawyer said the administration was concerned about what could happen if Costa Rica remains non-compliant. “We don’t have the luxury of violating a ruling by the Inter-American Court,” he said.

Sala IV will continue to accept opinions on the case for another two weeks before calling another hearing.

Trending Now

JetBlue Flash Sale: Fort Lauderdale to Liberia Flights Ends Today

Those looking for a deal on airfare and eyeing a trip between Florida and Costa Rica now have a chance to get one with...

Costa Rica’s Liberia Airport Fixes Runway Issues Overnight

Contractors began repairs on the runway at Daniel Oduber Quirós International Airport this week, focusing on sections that did not meet required standards after...

Tourist Numbers Dropped in Costa Rica During 2025’s First Seven Months

Costa Rica's tourism took a hit in the first seven months of 2025, with visitor numbers dropping compared to the previous year. By the...

Costa Rica Arrests Suspects Wanted by U.S. for Cocaine Smuggling

Authorities in Costa Rica arrested four men from the southern part of the country, all wanted by the United States for extradition on charges...

Costa Rica’s Guanacaste Makes Forbes’ Best Places to Visit in 2026

Forbes has spotlighted Guanacaste as one of the top six spots for travelers in 2026. The list also includes Nikko in Japan, Kona in...

Paris Louvre Robbery Targets Apollo Gallery Crown Jewels

Robbers wielding power tools scaled a furniture hoist outside the Louvre to make off with priceless jewelry from the world-renowned museum on Sunday, taking...
spot_img
Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Travel Insurance
Costa Rica Rocking Chait
Costa Rica Travel

Latest News from Costa Rica