HomeTopicsArts and CultureRemembering Leonard Nimoy with 'The Voyage Home'

Remembering Leonard Nimoy with ‘The Voyage Home’

There are innumerable reasons to mourn the loss of Leonard Nimoy, the actor, photographer and director who died Friday at age 83. There was his performance as Mr. Spock, the highly logical, half-human, half-alien crewman in “Star Trek.” Or you might appreciate his pictures, which showed Nimoy’s eye for unconventional female beauty. More recently, there was his charming presence on Twitter.

But today, I’m reminded just how much I love “Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home,” the second movie in the franchise Nimoy directed, and a film for which I feel such affection that I once hosted a screening party for it at which I served a cake frosted to look like a Tribble.

It would be hard to make a straightforward argument that “The Voyage Home” was a good movie, precisely. As Janet Maslin noted when the movie first arrived in theaters, “(Nimoy’s) technical expertise leaves much to be desired (in one special-effects sequence with a huge spacecraft hovering over a fishing vessel, the spacecraft doesn’t even cast a shadow).” What “The Voyage Home” does have, though, is a sense of humor and the value of life that’s missing from so many contemporary science fiction and action movies.

William Shatner, left, DeForest Kelley, center, and Leonard Nimoy pose on the set of the television series “Star Trek” in this undated photo.
NBC via The Washington Post

The plot of “The Voyage Home” is fairly typical for first-generation “Star Trek.” A mysterious probe shows up, seemingly posing a threat to 23rd-century Earth. When the crew members of the Enterprise figure out that it’s speaking a whale language, they have to go back to 1986, before humpbacks went extinct, and find one to return to the present with them to figure out what the probe is trying to communicate.

Their arrival in San Francisco is fraught with all sorts of cultural miscommunications, many of them surprisingly sophisticated and funny for an action movie. At one point, trying to explain away Spock’s clothes, Kirk (William Shatner) tells an incredulous observer that Spock was “part of the Free Speech Movement at Berkeley” and is still working off the effects of his drug consumption from the period.

And when they do locate a pair of whales, Spock and Kirk have to persuade the human oceanographer (Catherine Hicks) who studies the animals to view her charges with more respect. “They like you very much, but they are not the hell your whales,” Spock informs her after a chat with the humpbacks. It’s the rare genre movie that makes a point this obscure, and this political: that humans ought to think of animals as fellow citizens of our planet, deserving of protection and consideration, rather than as objects to be exploited or studied.

Since the “Star Trek” franchise was revitalized with different actors playing Kirk, Spock and their fellow crew members in 2009, the new movies have preserved the great interplay between the classic characters. But they’ve largely sacrificed the commitment to exploration and problem-solving that defined early “Star Trek” shows and movies.

Saving humpback whales would barely count as stakes in “Star Trek” and “Star Trek Into Darkness,” which feature the same kind of citywide destruction and bone-crunching slugging matches that appear in so many other science fiction action movies. These movies are fun, but they aren’t distinct in any particular way, and they certainly aren’t meaningful.

With “The Voyage Home,” Leonard Nimoy gave me a constant reminder that science fiction can be something more; that it can be sweeter, and sillier, and more expansive in its thinking about what makes the world wonderful and valuable. What does it profit us, after all, to save the world if we lose our whales?

—

Rosenberg writes The Post’s Act Four blog, at http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/act-four/

© 2015, The Washington Post

Trending Now

Costa Rica’s Dollar Slides Back Toward Its Record Low

The dollar closed Tuesday at 448.43 colones on Monex, 1.63 colones above its all-time low.

US Warns Costa Rica Town Halls Off Chinese Cameras, China Pushes Back

The US Embassy warned Costa Rica's municipalities about Chinese cameras and plate readers. China called the claims unfounded.

Costa Rica Moves to Dock Pay for Education Workers Who Joined Strike

Costa Rica's government is moving to dock a day's pay from education workers who joined Wednesday's march against cuts to public education, after the...

Costa Rica Falls 2-0 to Ecuador in Quito as the Bryan Ruiz Era Begins

Costa Rica lost 2-0 to Ecuador in Quito in Bryan Ruiz's debut, finishing with 10 men and losing a defender before Argentina.

Costa Rica Mourns Actor and TV Host Leonardo Perucci, Dead at 87

Leonardo Perucci, the Chilean-born actor and host of the 1980s TV hit Fantástico, died Tuesday at 87 after more than four decades on Costa Rican stages and screens.

Shakira Returns to Costa Rica in 2027 After More Than 15 Years

Shakira plans a January 31, 2027 show at Costa Rica's National Stadium, her first here since 2011.

Santa Cruz, Home to Tamarindo, Leads Guanacaste in Murders and Car Break-Ins

Santa Cruz has 22 of Guanacaste's 75 homicides this year, with Tamarindo on top. OIJ detained 10, including two police officers.

Costa Rica’s Dry Season Starts This Week in Guanacaste and the Central Valley

If you live in or are visiting Guanacaste or the Central Valley, the rain is about to switch off. Costa Rica's dry season settles...

El Salvador’s Marcelo Arévalo Opens ATP Finals With a Win

El Salvador’s Marcelo Arévalo and Croatian partner Mate Pavić began their ATP Finals campaign with a 7–6 (7), 6–4 victory over France’s Theo Arribagé...
Loading…

Latest News from Costa Rica

Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Car Rentals
Costa Rica Travel Insurance
Costa Rica Travel