No menu items!

COSTA RICA'S LEADING ENGLISH LANGUAGE NEWSPAPER

HomeTopicsEnvironment and WildlifeCosta Rica’s Environmental Scandal: Locals Fined, Foreign Hotels Untouched

Costa Rica’s Environmental Scandal: Locals Fined, Foreign Hotels Untouched

In a move that has ignited heated debate, Costa Rica’s Ministry of Environment and Energy (MINAE) has intensified enforcement against residents living in protected ecological zones, particularly in coastal maritime-terrestrial zones (ZMT). Yesterday it was reported that MINAE imposed multimillion-colón fines and prison sentences on Costa Rican citizens for residing in these restricted areas, which span 200 meters along the Pacific and Atlantic coasts.

The ZMT, designed to preserve ecosystems and ensure public access, prohibits private residences and unpermitted constructions. However, the crackdown has drawn criticism for its apparent leniency toward foreign-owned hotels and resorts operating in similar zones, raising questions about fairness and transparency in environmental governance.

The controversy centers on cases in coastal regions like Guanacaste and Puntarenas, where local families—some living in modest homes for decades—face severe penalties. For instance, a family in Playa Cabuyal was fined over ₡10 million (approximately $20,000 USD) and ordered to vacate their home, despite claiming ancestral rights to the land.

Meanwhile, luxury hotels, many owned by foreign investors, continue to operate in ecologically sensitive areas, often with permits granted under questionable circumstances. Critics, including local advocacy groups, argue that MINAE’s selective enforcement disproportionately targets vulnerable Costa Ricans while shielding powerful tourism interests. “It’s a double standard,” said Ana López, a community leader in Nosara. “Locals are punished, but big resorts keep building.”

This issue resonates deeply with expats and tourists, who are drawn to Costa Rica’s eco-friendly reputation but increasingly scrutinize its environmental policies. Expats owning or renting properties near protected zones may face heightened risks of legal disputes or property devaluation. Tourists, particularly those seeking sustainable travel, may question the authenticity of Costa Rica’s green image when luxury developments appear to skirt regulations. A report last year by NATIVU highlighted that unclear ZMT regulations have long complicated real estate transactions, advising foreigners to verify permits meticulously before investing.

MINAE defends its actions, stating that protecting biodiversity is paramount. In a press release, the ministry emphasized that illegal constructions harm ecosystems like mangroves and turtle nesting sites. However, the lack of transparency in how permits are granted to hotels—often linked to corruption scandals—undermines public trust. Recent posts on social media echo this sentiment, with users calling for equal enforcement and accountability.

As Costa Rica balances tourism growth with environmental preservation, this controversy underscores the need for clearer regulations and equitable enforcement. Expats and tourists should stay informed, as shifts in ZMT policies could impact coastal living and travel experiences.

Trending Now

The Cocos-Galapagos Swimway Will Create a Legacy for Costa Rica and the World!

At the UN Oceans Conference in Nice, France, which Costa Rica is co-sponsoring, President Rodrigo Chaves Robles has an opportunity to make history by...

Former Nicaraguan President Violeta Chamorro Dies in San José at 95

Violeta Barrios de Chamorro, Nicaragua’s first female president and a key figure in ending her country’s civil war, passed away peacefully this morning in...

Costa Rica’s Tourism Minister Dismisses Crime and Currency Concerns

Tourism Minister William Rodríguez López addressed growing concerns about crime and the strengthening colón’s impact on Costa Rica’s tourism industry, asserting that these issues...

Costa Rica’s President Stirs Debate with Oil Exploration Stance

President Rodrigo Chaves has sparked controversy with his recent comments on oil exploration and the Escazú Agreement, defending his positions in an interview with...

Panama Arrests Banana Union Leader After Chiquita Strike Ends

Panamanian authorities arrested Francisco Smith, leader of the banana workers’ union SITRAIBANA, accusing him of orchestrating road blockades during a six-week strike against Chiquita...

Canada’s Porter Airlines to Launch Direct Costa Rica Flights

Porter Airlines is gearing up to connect Canada with Costa Rica, following approval from the Canadian Transportation Agency (CTA) to operate direct international flights....
spot_img
Costa Rica Tours
Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Travel Insurance
Costa Rica Rocking Chait
Costa Rica Travel

Latest News from Costa Rica