No menu items!

COSTA RICA'S LEADING ENGLISH LANGUAGE NEWSPAPER

HomeCosta RicaCourt Order Freezes Costa Rica Trawling Studies

Court Order Freezes Costa Rica Trawling Studies

Costa Rica’s Administrative and Civil Court has taken decisive action in response to concerns raised by the MarViva Foundation, ordering the immediate suspension of new trawling studies in the country’s waters.

The court declared the measure admissible, citing an imminent and irreparable danger to marine ecosystems and state finances.

This legal development is a direct response to a series of irregularities and flaws that have been identified, conflicting with normative dispositions issued by the Constitutional Chamber.

These irregularities include technical deficiencies in the project, developmental flaws, and potential environmental harm that could lead to irreparable damage, thus violating the constitutional right outlined in Article 50.

As part of the court’s decision, there is an order to suspend all ongoing fishing activities and any other related acts by the Costa Rican Institute of Fisheries and Aquaculture (INCOPESCA) that could facilitate the execution of the controversial study. This includes the issuance of new fishing permits and agreements by the Board of Directors endorsing the initiative.

The suspension will remain in effect until a substantive resolution is reached for MarViva’s lawsuit, filed back in May.

“This precautionary measure signifies a resolute step by the court to protect marine ecosystems and defend the fishing resources crucial for thousands of artisanal fishermen and their families. Amid inconsistencies and a lack of transparency, this ‘study’ is riddled with technical and methodological shortcomings, posing a considerable risk to the sea, coastal economies, and public finances. We trust in our country’s democracy and the rule of law, and we respectfully applaud the court’s decision,” stated Katherine Arroyo, MarViva’s Advocacy Manager.

The precautionary measure will remain in effect until a definitive judgment is reached for MarViva’s lawsuit, aiming to annul the trawling reactivation study in Costa Rica.

New Trawling Studies Face Scrutiny for Inconsistencies

President Rodrigo Chaves announced in September 2022 that new technical studies would be conducted to revive shrimp fishing in Costa Rican waters. These studies, approved by the INCOPESCA Board of Directors, were scheduled to commence in the first quarter of 2023.

However, MarViva, along with academia, conservation organizations, and renowned scientists, raised questions about the study’s methodology and transparency. The study faced criticism for failing to meet minimum requirements, and these concerns were not exclusive to MarViva.

Based on a flawed research proposal, INCOPESCA issued fishing permits authorizing commercial shrimp exploitation through trawling. MarViva denounced INCOPESCA’s formalization of these decisions as illegal acts that should be declared null and void.

MarViva argued that the proposal fell short of the Constitutional Chamber’s requirements, as detailed in previous resolutions. These resolutions outline the minimum components a scientific investigation should encompass when analyzing the social, economic, and environmental viability of trawling in Costa Rica.

Trending Now

Costa Rica Route 32 Remains Closed After Large Landslide Near Zurquí

Traffic came to a standstill yesterda afternoon on National Route 32 after a massive landslide forced the complete closure of one of the country’s...

IKEA Plans To Open First Store in Costa Rica

IKEA plans to open its first store in Costa Rica after signing a franchise agreement with Sarton Group. The deal announced today gives Sarton...

The Day Costa Rica Stopped to Celebrate Claudia Poll’s Olympic Victory

In the decades I have lived here, there were two sporting events that were so big that the country came to a brief standstill....

La Negrita: Faith, Unity, and the Heart of Costa Rica

Today, thousands of pilgrims from across Costa Rica are arriving at the Basilica of Our Lady of the Angels in Cartago. They come on...

Costa Rica Urged to Fix Broken Forestry Permit System

A new report by the Comptroller General's Office (CGR) revealed that poor management of the National System of Conservation Areas (SINAC) by the Ministry...

Legal Battle Erupts Over Hutchison’s Panama Canal Port Concession

Panama’s president, José Raúl Mulino, said that he wants to negotiate a new concession contract with the Hong Kong–based Hutchison Holdings subsidiary to continue...
spot_img
Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Travel Insurance
Costa Rica Rocking Chait
Costa Rica Travel

Latest News from Costa Rica