HomeNewsCosta RicaSix found dead in Buenos Aires, Puntarenas: OIJ

Six found dead in Buenos Aires, Puntarenas: OIJ

Six people were killed Sunday on a farm in Llano Bonito de Buenos Aires, Puntarenas, according to the Judicial Investigation Police (OIJ).

The victims include a U.S. citizen, who resided in Costa Rica, surnamed Sandusky. He was 61 years old. The remaining victims include three men and two women, all Costa Rican adults from the Perez Zeledón area, though OIJ says the identification process remains preliminary.

The U.S. citizen was further identified as Stephen Paul Sandusky by La Nacion, which reported that the retiree had moved to Costa Rica in the late nineties.

OIJ says the U.S. citizen had contacted a man surnamed Quesada Cascante, 44, who is a mechanic, to repair agricultural machinery on his property. Quesada Cascante, his wife, his son and the two others arrived at the farm on Sunday morning.

Later on Sunday, having not heard from their relatives for several hours, family of the Perez Zeledón residents arrived at the farm to search for them and found them dead.

OIJ did not name persons of interest but indicated robbery was a possible motive for the crime. The property is located 3-4 km from the nearest public road in Buenos Aires, OIJ said, and was owned by the U.S. citizen.

Many of the bodies were significantly burned, and at least three had apparent gunshot wounds, OIJ said in its preliminary report.

The U.S. Embassy told the Associated Press it could not comment on the case because of privacy concerns.

An interdisciplinary team from OIJ arrived at the scene Monday to confirm identities and the cause of death, the organization said.

The incident would represent the deadliest known multiple homicide in Costa Rica this year. Costa Rica is the most peaceful Central American nation, though its homicide rate remains above the World Health Organization’s benchmark as constituting an epidemic.

This is a developing story and will be updated with further information.

Trending Now

Costa Rica Pilot Faces Discipline After Aviation Safety Criticism

Costa Rican police pilot David Damazzio Fernández faces possible suspension or dismissal over media comments about aviation safety oversight and criticism posted on social media.

Dental tourism, because Medicare doesn’t cover for dental treatment

C. Everett Koop, known for his tenure as U.S. surgeon general during the Reagan administration, was renowned for his pediatric surgery and attention to...

Costa Rica Fires Foreign Minister After Trump Meeting Dispute

President Laura Fernández fired Foreign Minister Manuel Tovar today after saying he failed to tell her about a high-level security meeting with U.S. President...

Costa Rican Influencer Julián Valverde Released by ICE Without Bond

Costa Rican content creator Julián Valverde was released from U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement custody in Florida on Sunday, Sept. 20, after five days...

Pura Vida: Past the Point of No Return

Growing up on the Lower East Side of New York certainly didn’t prepare me for the culture shock of moving to a sleepy little...

Jacó Beach Is Changing as New Residents and Major Brands Move In

For decades, Jacó’s economy has revolved around the beach. Surfing, hotels, restaurants, nightlife and weekend visitors from San José helped turn the Central Pacific...

New Costa Rica Law Requires Wildlife Crossings on Public Infrastructure

Costa Rica now has a law requiring wildlife crossings on public infrastructure projects, but the regulation that will actually put it into practice could...

Human Trafficking Cases Reach 16-Year High in Costa Rica

Costa Rica recorded 83 human trafficking victims in 2025, the highest number reported in any single year since at least 2010, according to figures...

Costa Rica Ranks Fifth in the World for Retirees in Global Relocation Index

Costa Rica ranks 20th out of 192 countries and territories in the 2026 Global Relocation Index, and fifth in the world for retirees, according...
🌴 The Weekly Pura Vida

Costa Rica, Once a Week

The week's top stories, weather & insider tips — delivered every Sunday. One email, zero clutter.

🔒 Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Loading…

Latest News from Costa Rica

Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Car Rentals
Costa Rica Travel Insurance
Costa Rica Travel