HomeTopicsEnvironment and WildlifeCosta Rica Oilcapades! Ex-Minister Squeezed Out of Sweet Crude Deal

Costa Rica Oilcapades! Ex-Minister Squeezed Out of Sweet Crude Deal

A former Costa Rican government minister is suing a U.S. energy company over a soured oil concession deal that never came to fruition. Roberto Dobles Mora, the former Minister of Environment and Energy, filed a lawsuit in September against Black Hills Corporation (BHC) alleging breach of contract over royalty payments he claims he is owed.

The dispute dates back over a decade to when Dobles entered a consulting agreement with BHC after resigning from his ministerial role in 2009 amidst a separate corruption investigation. As outlined in an exposé by Amelia Rueda, Dobles agreed to advise BHC for $4,000 per month as the company sought oil and natural gas concessions in Costa Rica.

A “Royalty Agreement” was also established entitling Dobles to up to 3% royalties on any oil and gas extracted under the concessions. However, the concessions were never finalized as BHC failed to submit the required environmental impact assessments to move exploration plans forward.

Dobles contends BHC deliberately stalled the concession approval process, hesitant to disclose its overseas fossil fuel interests to stock market analysts and regulators back in the U.S. With the concessions inactive for years, Dobles alleges he lost out on tens of millions in royalty payments he was counting on.

The consulting and royalty agreements relate to exploration rights originally awarded to Mallon Oil Company in 2000 covering over 9,300 square kilometers in northern Costa Rica. BHC acquired Mallon in 2003, inheriting the concessions.

However, BHC struggled to abide by Costa Rica’s stringent environmental policies. Mallon Oil even sued the Costa Rican government in 2011 arguing an environmental impact assessment should not be required simply to begin survey work on the land. Mallon lost this lawsuit on appeal in 2015.

By November 2015, BHC terminated its consulting contract with Dobles but upheld the royalty agreement. In January 2020, after opting not to renew the annual concessions guarantee, BHC lost access to the oil and gas fields completely.

Dobles first faced corruption allegations himself in 2009 when he resigned as Environmental Minister during an investigation into whether he had shown favoritism towards a family-owned mining company. However, he was eventually acquitted of those charges.

Ironically, it was decisions made by Dobles while serving under former president Oscar Arias that opened the door for oil and gas concessions in the first place. This included approving the controversial Crucitas gold mining project in 2008 declaring it in the national interest despite environmental concerns.

The unsuccessful deal with BHC that Dobles is now suing over was crafted in the aftermath of him stepping down from the Arias administration. But Dobles suffered another blow when a U.S. appellate court dismissed the $42 million damages claim against Black Hills Corporation this past October.

With Costa Rica long-considered an eco-friendly bastion, the irony of its former environmental minister pursuing oil concessions after leaving office has not gone unnoticed. And the latest lawsuit only adds another twist to this ongoing saga.

Trending Now

Costa Rica Flights Caught in Only the Third Nationwide US Ground Stop Ever

The FAA stopped all US departures Friday. Here's what it means if you're flying to or from Costa Rica.

Costa Rica Moves to Demolish Narco Airstrips Without a Conviction

A Costa Rica bill would let authorities destroy clandestine airstrips without a final ruling and freeze land linked to them. It now heads to a floor vote.

Italian Wanted in 2021 Santa Cruz Killing Extradited to France

Costa Rica extradited two men to France, including an Italian investigated in the 2021 killing of a French citizen in Santa Cruz, Guanacaste.

Costa Rica Asks You to Cut Water Use as the El Niño Dry Season Begins

Costa Rica's water utility wants you to save water as the dry season starts this week under a strong El Niño. There is no rationing yet. Here is what it is asking.

Heavy Storms Could Drop Nearly 3 Inches of Rain on Costa Rica Today

Short, intense downpours, thunderstorms and gusts up to 80 km/h are forecast for the Central Valley, the Caribbean and the northern zone Friday afternoon.

Costa Rica Is One Vote From Co-Hosting the 2031 Women’s World Cup

Costa Rica is one step away from co-hosting the 2031 FIFA Women's World Cup, the biggest tournament in women's soccer. FIFA said Wednesday that...

ATP Finals 2026 Set for Turin Without Sinner as Four Newcomers Join Field

The 2026 ATP Finals will begin Sunday, November 15, with a different look from recent years. World No. 1 Alexander Zverev leads an eight-player...

Costa Rica Bill Would Let Towns Cap Airbnb Rentals

Costa Rica's municipalities could limit how many short-term rentals operate in a neighborhood, a residential building or even on certain floors of a condominium...

San José’s Festival de la Luz Swaps Floats for 10 Giant Balloons This Year

San José's Festival de la Luz is December 12, with no floats this year. See the new route, balloon lineup, lights switch-on date and district festivals.
Loading…

Latest News from Costa Rica

Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Car Rentals
Costa Rica Travel Insurance
Costa Rica Travel