No menu items!

COSTA RICA'S LEADING ENGLISH LANGUAGE NEWSPAPER

HomeNewsCosta RicaCosta Rican police arrest U.S. men suspected in $9 million scam

Costa Rican police arrest U.S. men suspected in $9 million scam

Judicial Investigation Police (OIJ) agents detained five U.S. men suspected of running a criminal gang that allegedly swindled $9 million from U.S. seniors through a call-center scam.

Agents arrested the suspects at various simultaneous raids on Wednesday in locations on the west side of the San José area: Pavas, León XIII and Escazú.

The OIJ said in a news release on Thursday that the suspects allegedly ran the scam through a San José based call-center. They called people living in the United States and told them they had won a cash prize and could collect after wiring a refundable fee to a bank account in Costa Rica, authorities said.

Police identified detainees by the last names Dodt, Jordan, Sniffen, Nastasi and Fink. All of them are required by U.S. judicial authorities for the crimes of fraud, illicit association and money laundering.

A sixth member of the group, a woman by the last name of Mommers, remains at large.

The OIJ said agents proceeded with the arrests after receiving warrants issued by Interpol. U.S. officials also filed extradition requests for all the suspects in order to take them to North Carolina.

Retirees as targets

The OIJ report states that the suspects conducted the scam by impersonating agents of the U.S. Federal Trade Commission and other public agencies. The group targeted primarily retired people and other citizens over 55 in the United States. Victims were told that, in order to claim their prize, they would need to pay a refundable fee for taxes and for insuring safe delivery.

The scam then went even further, authorities said. Once victims were convinced of their winnings and had made an initial payment, they received another call telling them that their prize amount had been increased. They were informed that because of this, they would need to pay higher taxes and a larger insurance policy before getting their prize, the Prosecutors’ Office explained.

The indictment sent from North Carolina includes evidence of many of the transfers that victims wired to Costa Rican accounts between 2010-2014. Figures ranged from $500 to $1,850 dollars.

The extradition process could take up to six months, the OIJ confirmed.

Trending Now

Route 27 Goes One-Way at 2 p.m. and the Weather Turns with It

If you spent the mid-year break at the beach, today is the day most people head home — and two things will shape your...

Costa Rica Hospitals Cancel Surgeries Amid Specialist Shortage

More than 199,000 patients were waiting for surgery in Costa Rica’s public healthcare system at the end of 2025 as a severe shortage of...

Costa Rica Faces Water Rationing and Wildfire Risk as El Niño Deepens

A strong El Niño has taken hold over Costa Rica and will keep much of the country drier and hotter than normal through the...

Costa Rica’s San Jose Airport Is Getting Its First Hotel

Costa Rica's San Jose airport is about to gain something no other airport in Central America has: a hotel guests can reach on foot...

How to Watch the World Cup Final Weekend in Costa Rica

The World Cup ends today, and you can watch the final from Costa Rica without staying up late or paying for a seat in...

Panama Bill Would Require Influencers to Disclose Paid Posts

Panama’s National Assembly is considering a bill that would require social media influencers and content creators to clearly identify when their posts are paid...

Brandon Nakashima Wins First UTS Tournament in South America

Brandon Nakashima claimed the title at the Ultimate Tennis Showdown’s first tournament in South America, defeating 17-year-old Brazilian Guto Miguel in a tightly contested...

Costa Rica’s Public Health Waiting Lists Hit 1.4 million, Audit Finds

A newly surfaced internal audit at the Caja Costarricense de Seguro Social (CCSS) has intensified scrutiny of Costa Rica's public healthcare system, and it...

Costa Rica Plans Integrated Train and Bus Network to Ease Traffic Congestion

Costa Rica's national railway institute is pushing to link the country's trains, buses, and taxis into a single coordinated network, a plan its backers...
L. Arias
L. Arias
Reporter | The Tico Times |
🌴 The Weekly Pura Vida

Costa Rica, Once a Week

The week's top stories, weather & insider tips — delivered every Sunday. One email, zero clutter.

🔒 Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Loading…

Latest News from Costa Rica

Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Car Rentals
Costa Rica Travel Insurance
Costa Rica Travel