• Costa Rica Coffee Guide

Fish heads debate billfish fishing future

August 15, 2008

The Costa Rican Fisheries Institute (INCOPESCA) held a meeting yesterday with commercial and sportfishing camps, as well as the conservation group, The Billfish Foundation, to address the rapidly declining billfish numbers in Costa Rican waters.

The debate has grown intense between commercial and sportfishing sectors, who both claim the other is encroaching on their waters. In June, there were several accounts of commercial fishing rigs harassing sportfishing vessels and tourists with machine guns, helicopters and even explosives.

Guatemalan and Mexican sportfishing industries have prospered in the wake of the decline of the Costa Rican billfish population.

“The commercial fishing and sportfishing industries are in crisis,” said Nelson Ehrhardt, professor of Marine Biology and Fisheries at University of Miami in Coral Gables, Florida. “ Costa Rica is losing status as an avenue for sportfishing. Your neighbors are gaining the best clients. The Costa Rican contingent is the region´s big loser right now.”

Between 2000 and 2006, the average sailfish haul in national tournaments dipped from roughly eight fish to one, and sportfishing boats failed to catch any fish on 60 percent of outings in 2007, as opposed to 37 percent that came up empty-handed in 2006.

There are also claims the commercial fishers underreport their harvests, further abating the number of billfish. The situation is exacerbated by the fact that Costa Rica is the fifth largest billfish exporter and the U.S. the second largest importer, says Ehrhardt.

In wake of this, some have called for a ban on billfish, but others have called that excessive.

“I don´t believe the voices that cry, ‘We have to (ban the harvest of billfish),´” said INCOPESCA president Carlos Villalobos. “That is the voice of dictatorship. I believe in the voice of sustainable development as shown by science.”

But Ehrhardt said some of the biggest problems are beyond Costa Rica, literally, but rather are due to Asian fleets that patrol the international waters just beyond Costa Rican shores. Besides depleting billfish populations with their fishing, Ehrhardt says, “(Taiwanese, Japanese and Chinese boats) release 50, 60 or 100 miles of line. Chlorophyll deposits are deoxidizing the water, creating these dead zones.”

Regardless of the solution the group reaches, Costa Rica stands to lose billions of tourist dollars if they mismanage the resource.

“This is a real tangible problem off the coasts of South, Central and North America,” Ehrhardt said. “ Costa Rica is losing the market power in a very important industry. If there is no sportfishing, there is no more development. Property values will fall.”

INCOPESCA plans to announce proposals and conclusions from the meeting today.

You may be interested

Costa Rican diet contains too much salt, Health Ministry says
Health
4747 views
Health
4747 views

Costa Rican diet contains too much salt, Health Ministry says

Alejandro Zúñiga - March 9, 2021

The average Costa Rican adult consumes twice the recommended value of salt each day, according to the Health Ministry. Ticos ingest…

Costa Rica creates commission to address gender unemployment gap
Costa Rica
2552 views
Costa Rica
2552 views

Costa Rica creates commission to address gender unemployment gap

Alejandro Zúñiga - March 9, 2021

In context of International Women's Day, Costa Rican leaders on Monday signed a decree to create a commission to address…

Vaccinated people don’t have to self-isolate after Covid contact
Costa Rica
16423 views
Costa Rica
16423 views

Vaccinated people don’t have to self-isolate after Covid contact

Alejandro Zúñiga - March 8, 2021

People who are fully vaccinated against Covid-19 won’t have to isolate if they are a close contact to someone who…