The men who killed American surfer Kurt Van Dyke in February allegedly belonged to a group linked to Alejandro Arias Monge, the alleged drug trafficker known as “Diablo,” according to the court file in the case. The file also alleges that Van Dyke was bound and tortured to force him to reveal the PINs for his bank cards.
Van Dyke, 66, was found dead on Feb. 14 in Hone Creek, near Cahuita on Costa Rica’s southern Caribbean coast. A Santa Cruz, California, native known in surfing circles as “King,” he had run Hotel Puerto Viejo for decades. His killing was first reported as a robbery.
Two suspects are in custody. A 31-year-old woman surnamed Arroyo RamÃrez, who had a long relationship with Van Dyke, and a man surnamed Gutiérrez VÃctor were detained on Nov. 12. On Nov. 15, the Talamanca Criminal Court ordered both held for six months of pretrial detention while prosecutors investigate them for aggravated homicide.
Neither has been charged or convicted, and both are presumed innocent. The allegations described below come from the prosecution’s case file and have not been tested in court.
According to the file, the plan took shape on the morning of Feb. 14. Arroyo RamÃrez allegedly persuaded Van Dyke to come to her home in Hone Creek under false pretenses. Prosecutors allege that once he was there, she sent WhatsApp messages telling the others he was unprotected and how to get in.
The file states that the attackers entered, immobilized Van Dyke and tied his hands and feet. They then allegedly tortured him and inflicted stab wounds as they tried to obtain his bank PINs. Prosecutors attribute the killing to a structured group acting together to seize his assets and take his life.
A neighbor called 911 at 10:35 a.m. to report that armed men had broken in, restrained both people inside and stolen the woman’s car and phone, according to the file. Security cameras recorded Van Dyke calling for help at about 10 a.m. Investigators found no sign of forced entry.
The medical-legal report concluded that Van Dyke died of asphyxia caused by compression of the neck, with a fractured hyoid bone, and that he had been tortured. He was found under a bed with his hands and feet bound, a sheet around his head and multiple stab wounds. Investigators allege that the woman staged the robbery and reported her own vehicle stolen to conceal her role.
The car was later recovered in good condition, and investigators determined that her account did not match the evidence. The file also describes alleged threats in the months before the killing. On Jan. 4, Arroyo RamÃrez allegedly demanded $1,500 from Van Dyke and threatened to send people from Diablo’s group to harm another former partner of his and their son.
Arias Monge was captured on July 24 in San Bernardino de Sarapiquà at the end of an operation authorities named Némesis, and he is being held at La Reforma prison. Reports on the file have not said whether he is a suspect in the Van Dyke case. Investigations into his network have already reached a police officer and two Pococà judges.
The case is being handled under file 26-000171-0829-PE by the organized crime unit of the Limón Prosecutor’s Office, under the supervision of the deputy prosecutor’s office for money laundering. The OIJ is still looking for two more men believed to have taken part in the attack.
Anyone with information can contact the OIJ’s confidential line at 800-8000-645.





