HomeCosta RicaCosta Rica Shifts UN Stance on Israel as Grynspan Leads Race for...

Costa Rica Shifts UN Stance on Israel as Grynspan Leads Race for Top UN Job

Costa Rica abstained today on four United Nations draft resolutions concerning Israel, the occupied Palestinian territories and Palestinian refugees, withholding support from measures it voted for at the same stage in November 2025. The votes took place in the General Assembly’s Fourth Committee, formally the Special Political and Decolonization Committee, which each year takes up texts on the UN agency for Palestinian refugees and on Israeli practices in territories occupied since 1967. All four passed by wide margins, and the committee’s recorded votes listed Costa Rica among the abstentions each time.

The first text backs the operations of the UN Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA), whose mandate the General Assembly has extended to June 30, 2029. It deplores Israeli laws restricting the agency and calls on Israel to respect its privileges and immunities. It passed 143 to 9, with 20 abstentions, with the United States and Israel among the votes against.

The second affirms Palestinian refugees’ rights to their property and the income it generates and passed 155 to 9 with 9 abstentions. The third reaffirms that Israel’s 1981 extension of its laws to the occupied Syrian Golan is illegal, passing 149 to 8 with 14 abstentions. The fourth declares Israeli settlements in the occupied Palestinian territory, including East Jerusalem, and in the Golan illegal, and calls for an immediate halt to settlement activity. It passed 143 to 11, with 17 abstentions.

Costa Rica supported all four in committee last year, when the tallies were broadly similar. Within the region, Panama and Ecuador abstained on three of this year’s four texts, while Argentina, Colombia and Paraguay voted against at least one. The change fits a wider pattern. On Nov. 11, in the Assembly’s Second Committee, Costa Rica abstained on a resolution asking Israel to compensate Lebanon for a 2006 oil spill, which it had backed in 2024 and 2025, and repeated its 2025 abstention on a text on Palestinian natural resources. Over the past week, Costa Rica has abstained on six Israel-related texts, five of which it supported a year earlier.

The shift did not begin with the current administration. In December 2025, under former President Rodrigo Chaves, Costa Rica voted for the settlements and Golan texts in committee, then abstained on both when they reached the full General Assembly, ending a record of support on settlements dating back at least a decade. What is new this week is that the abstentions now come at the first stage and extend to UNRWA and refugee property.

The votes are the clearest sign yet that President Laura Fernández, who took office May 8 as Chaves’s chosen successor, intends to carry that alignment further. Shortly after her inauguration, the office of Israeli President Isaac Herzog said she had told him she was willing to raise Costa Rica’s representation in Jerusalem to embassy level. The Foreign Ministry declined at the time to confirm or deny that account, saying any decision would be communicated through official channels.

Costa Rica’s embassy has been in Tel Aviv since 2006, when it was moved from Jerusalem in line with Security Council Resolution 478. The country signed a free trade agreement with Israel in December 2025, now before the Legislative Assembly, and opened a trade and innovation office in Jerusalem in March.

The government has not publicly explained Wednesday’s abstentions. Fernández’s foreign minister, career diplomat Ana Elena Pinto, took office Oct. 15 after the president dismissed Manuel Tovar.

The votes come in the middle of the most consequential diplomatic campaign Costa Rica has run in years. Rebeca Grynspan, the former vice president who heads UN Trade and Development, is the front-runner to succeed António Guterres as secretary-general when his term ends Dec. 31. In the Security Council’s eighth informal straw poll on Nov. 5, she received 12 “encourage” votes and three “discourage” votes, her strongest showing so far.

Her path still runs through the council’s five permanent members, any of which can veto her. Analysts have identified the United States and Russia as the main risks. Washington’s reservations have been linked to reports from her agency that criticized Israel’s actions in Gaza and the West Bank, while Moscow’s have been tied to her disagreement with its justifications for suspending the Black Sea grain deal.

That leaves Costa Rica facing competing pressures. A voting record closer to Washington’s could ease concerns in the capital with the most leverage over the outcome. But the council’s choice must still be formally appointed by the 193-member General Assembly, where Arab and Muslim-majority states form a large bloc.

In May, Carlos Murillo, director of the University of Costa Rica’s development observatory, warned that Arab support for Grynspan could begin to erode if Costa Rica moved toward recognizing Jerusalem as Israel’s capital. No delegation has publicly linked its position on her candidacy to Costa Rica’s votes this week, and Grynspan, as an international civil servant, has no role in her country’s ballots.

The four committee texts now go to the full General Assembly for final adoption, typically in early December, the same stretch in which the Security Council is expected to try to settle on a recommendation for the next secretary-general. For a country that built its diplomatic identity on multilateralism and international law, the votes mark a clear change in direction. Whether that change carries a cost for Costa Rica, or for Grynspan, among its Arab and Latin American partners should become clearer within weeks.

Trending Now

Blocked Estuary May Explain Playa Langosta Fish Die-Off

Sand blocking an estuary's connection to the ocean, combined with reduced freshwater flow during a period of little rain, may explain the mass fish...

US Ground Stop Canceled 15 Costa Rica Flights. Here’s What to Expect Today

Updated Saturday afternoon with the cause of the outage, Saturday's cancellations and when flights should be back to normal. The nationwide US ground stop that...

Gunmen Kill Costa Rican Journalist Camilo Rodríguez on Route 32 in Heredia

Prosecutors will examine whether earlier death threats are linked to the killing, which the attorney general called the third murder of a journalist in Costa Rica.

Masks Are Back at Some Costa Rica Hospitals. Here’s Where You Need One

Several Costa Rica public hospitals require masks again as respiratory cases rise. See where you need one before your visit.

Four in Ten Costa Ricans Hold Back Opinions on Social Media Out of Fear

Four in ten Costa Ricans say they have held back from sharing their opinions on social media for fear of the consequences, according to...

Gas Cylinders Pulled in Costa Rica – Here’s How to Check Yours

If your stove runs on a propane tank, the cylinder you swap at the corner store can be pulled from sale if inspectors find...

Pura Vida: The Dream, the Reality and Everything in Between

Is Costa Rica's famous way of life everything we imagine it to be? Or is the real meaning of Pura Vida something we only...

Costa Rica Moves to Dock Pay for Education Workers Who Joined Strike

Costa Rica's government is moving to dock a day's pay from education workers who joined Wednesday's march against cuts to public education, after the...

Prosecutors Say They Found Signs of Abuse at Costa Rica’s New Megaprison

Costa Rica's attorney general says prosecutors found signs of possible torture at the CACCO megaprison. The Justice Ministry called the visit a show.
Loading…

Latest News from Costa Rica

Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Car Rentals
Costa Rica Travel Insurance
Costa Rica Travel