HomeTopicsCrimeProsecutors Investigate Rodrigo Chaves Over Turrúcares Landfill Offer

Prosecutors Investigate Rodrigo Chaves Over Turrúcares Landfill Offer

Costa Rica’s Attorney General’s Office has opened a criminal investigation into former president Rodrigo Chaves, now minister of the Presidency and of Finance, for alleged influence peddling linked to public works he offered an Alajuela community if local officials dropped their legal fight against a proposed landfill.

The Fiscalía General said it opened the case in response to published reports and a complaint it received. The office confirmed the investigation on Monday, Nov. 16. Prosecutors declined to provide further details, citing the confidentiality of the preparatory stage under Article 295 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. The opening of a case does not mean that criminal responsibility has been established.

The investigation centers on a public meeting Chaves led on Nov. 4 at the high school in Turrúcares, a district of Alajuela. Several ministers, government officials, members of the Alajuela Municipal Council and community representatives attended.

At the meeting, Chaves presented a package of projects for the district, including a technical high school, a CEN-CINAI childcare center, care centers for older adults, sports facilities, and repairs to national routes 721 and 136 and their bridges. He made the investments conditional on the Municipal Council withdrawing lawsuits that seek to annul the land-use permits for a landfill planned at the Bajo Pita property in San Miguel de Turrúcares.

When Education Minister Leonardo Sánchez said staff would assess land for the technical school, Chaves instructed that the work not begin while the municipality’s lawsuits remained in place. The value of the package has been reported differently. Chaves announced works valued at about 6 billion colones (about $13.4 million). The Presidency has since cited a figure of about 100 million colones (about $223,000) in infrastructure projects.

The landfill would be built by Empresas Berthier EBI de Costa Rica, which the government has promoted as an environmental technology park. The Municipality of Alajuela granted the project’s land-use permits more than a decade ago but later moved to annul them through lesividad proceedings, arguing the project conflicts with the canton’s zoning plan.

Investors linked to the Canadian company Berthier EBI and to Bajo Pita S.A. then filed an arbitration claim against Costa Rica at the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID). Chaves told residents the state faces potential exposure of up to $150 million and that the municipality’s lawsuits weaken Costa Rica’s defense.

He also attached a deadline. Chaves said the offer would be withdrawn once the government had to pay for the country’s legal defense in the arbitration, a cost he estimated at 2 billion colones (about $4.5 million), with the process starting Dec. 2.

No signed agreement guaranteeing that the investors would withdraw the arbitration was presented at the meeting. Legal specialists Álvaro Sagot and Nicolás Boeglin have questioned Chaves’s reading of the case, arguing that the state has legal defenses available and that the claim may be time-barred.

Chaves has rejected accusations of extortion, saying his intervention was intended to warn of the economic consequences the country would face if it lost the international case. No response from Chaves to the opening of the criminal case had been published as of Wednesday morning.

Lawmakers from the National Liberation Party, the Social Christian Unity Party and the Broad Front accused Chaves of blackmail the day after the meeting. An opposition motion condemning his statements, filed Nov. 9, was rejected 31 to 24, with the ruling Pueblo Soberano party voting against it.

In Alajuela, the decision rests with the council. Council president Jorge Arturo Campos described the offer as a trade-off and said residents should take part in the decision, while Chaves rejected a popular consultation and said the council’s 11 members should decide. Two weeks after the meeting, Campos said the council had received no formal request to vote on the landfill and had nothing on its agenda. Turrúcares residents have protested at council sessions and want the court challenges kept in place.

Influence peddling carries a penalty of two to five years in prison under the Law Against Corruption and Illicit Enrichment in Public Service. Any prosecution would face an additional hurdle. As a minister, Chaves holds immunity from prosecution, meaning the Supreme Court’s full bench would first have to approve a request to lift it before the Legislative Assembly votes, where 38 votes, a two-thirds majority, are required.

A separate request by prosecutors to lift his immunity, in a case over alleged parallel financing of his 2022 presidential campaign, has been stalled for months by vacancies among substitute justices on the Constitutional Chamber. The dispute unfolds as the waste disposal capacity tightens. Olivier Álvarez, president of the Association of Chemical Engineers and Allied Professionals (CIQPA), said in remarks published Wednesday that three or four of Costa Rica’s seven active landfills are months, not years, from the end of their useful life, and that the Greater Metropolitan Area needs a new disposal site.

Álvarez said 55% to 60% of household waste is organic and roughly 20% could be recycled if kept clean, and he called for a model that recovers more material rather than one that depends on finding new places to bury garbage. Prosecutors have not said when the preliminary investigation might conclude.

Trending Now

Costa Rica Flights to the US Back on Track as Trump Blames Biden for Ground Stop

If you're flying between Costa Rica and the United States today, your flight should run close to schedule. The nationwide US ground stop that...

El Niño Could Leave 306,000 People in Costa Rica Short of Water

More than 306,000 people in Costa Rica could face problems getting drinking water as the strongest El Niño on record dries us out, according...

Gusts Up to 80 km/h Hit Costa Rica’s Mountains as a Windy, Dry Week Begins

Gusts up to 80 km/h (50 mph) are forecast in Costa Rica's mountains and La Cruz as trade winds settle in for the week.

Costa Rica President Says Jailed Gang Members Ordered Her Killing

President Laura Fernández said Monday that prison intelligence reports show gang members behind bars have ordered her assassination.

The Perfect Family Beach Day at Playa Carrillo, Costa Rica

This is between me and you. Don’t tell anybody else. We don’t want too many people overcrowding the places I’m about to tell you...

US Airline Seats to Costa Rica Fall 14% as Fares Climb

Scheduled US airline seats to Costa Rica are projected to fall 14% through March, with San José down 20%, Liberia down 3% and fares up as much as 45%.

Costa Rica Bill Would Let Towns Cap Airbnb Rentals

Costa Rica's municipalities could limit how many short-term rentals operate in a neighborhood, a residential building or even on certain floors of a condominium...

Finish Your Government Paperwork by Dec. 21 as Costa Rica Offices Close

The government has ordered seven days of collective vacation for public employees: Dec. 22, 23, 24, 28, 29, 30 and 31. With Christmas, New...

Teachers Strike Today as 11 Groups March Through Downtown San José

If you plan to drive, ride a bus or walk through downtown San José this morning, expect delays. Teachers' unions and public universities are...
Loading…

Latest News from Costa Rica

Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Car Rentals
Costa Rica Travel Insurance
Costa Rica Travel