HomeTopicsEnvironment and WildlifeCarbon Neutral Pledges: Are Companies Walking the Talk?

Carbon Neutral Pledges: Are Companies Walking the Talk?

Nearly half the world’s biggest companies have pledged to erase their carbon footprints by around mid-century, but only a handful have credible game plans for doing so, climate policy research groups said Monday.

Without tangible action from firms, the Net Zero Stocktake 2023 report warned, capping global warming at tolerable levels will likely remain out of reach.

Barely one degree Celsius of warming to date has made extreme weather more destructive and deadly, and UN climate experts have said the world could breach the Paris treaty limit of 1.5C above the preindustrial benchmark within a decade.

“The big question is whether existing net zero targets will acquire the measures of credibility quickly enough to keep the Paris Agreement’s temperature goals within reach,” said co-author John Lang from the Energy & Climate Intelligence Unit.

Taking into account national, regional and corporate pledges, some 90 percent of the global economy has climbed on board the ‘net zero’ bandwagon, up from 15 percent four years ago.

In business, 929 companies on the Forbes 2000 list have set targets to eliminate their emissions by around 2050, more than twice as many as in December 2020. 

But measuring these CO2-purging pledges against the yardstick of half-a-dozen standards for assessing net zero claims shows that almost all fall down badly on the details.

“Most entities that have pledged net zero do not meet minimum requirements for what good net zero looks like,” said Lang. Only four percent of corporate commitments are in line with five “starting line” criteria set out in the UN Race to Zero guidelines, one of the voluntary standards.   

These basic benchmarks include setting a specific net zero target; covering greenhouse gases other than CO2, such as methane and nitrous oxide; very limited use of carbon offsets, such as planting trees, instead of emissions reductions; and annual reporting on progress toward both interim and long-term targets.

Arguably no sector is under more pressure to decarbonise than fossil fuel companies, and 75 of the 112 largest of these firms have net zero targets today, 50 percent more than a year ago.

But most of these targets are “largely meaningless,” the report said, because they do not include so-called scope three emissions — downstream impacts such as CO2 released by the burning of the oil, gas or coal.

Overall, barely a third of corporate net zero targets examined included scope three.    

No rowing back

As pressure mounts, signs of a backlash against net zero commitments has emerged across the corporate landscape.

Last month half-a-dozen members of the Net Zero Insurance Alliance, launched in 2021, backed out of the group, and some large institutional investors have softened their net zero pledges as well.

“People are realising that it’s not a fad, and as they turn their attention to the ‘how’ of net zero we are seeing pushback,” said Lang.

“But there’s no rowing back from where we are now,” he added. “This is now a norm for the corporate world.” Gradually, voluntary compliance schemes will give way to regulations and shifts in market-based incentives, Lang predicted.

Already today, the Inflation Reduction Act (IRA) in the United States and the Net Zero Industry Act in the European Union are shifting hundreds of billions of dollars from carbon-polluting to clean energy.

Even the fossil fuel industry is not immune to mounting pressure as decarbonisation of the global economy accelerates.

In 2023, more than $1.7 trillion will be invested in carbon-free energy, compared to $1 trillion going into energy and power from oil, gas and coal, according to the International Energy Agency (IEA). For the first time this year, investment in solar power will outstrip that in oil.

And some incumbent energy firms, such Danish multinational Orsted, have successfully transitioned from fossil fuels to renewables.

“Slowly but surely the narrative is changing,” said Lang. “I do think we will live to see the day where the social license to operate of fossil fuel companies will be withdrawn.”

The NewClimate Institute, Oxford Net Zero, and Driven EnviroLab also contributed to the Net Zero Stocktake 2023 report. 

Trending Now

Pura Vida: The Dream, the Reality and Everything in Between

Is Costa Rica's famous way of life everything we imagine it to be? Or is the real meaning of Pura Vida something we only...

Costa Rica Plans Rent-to-Own Homes With Up to 100% Financing

Costa Rica's Housing Ministry is drafting a rent-to-own model. Families would rent a home for about five years at a fixed price, then buy it with financing that could reach 95% to 100%. A bill is expected early next year.

Satellite Tracking Reveals New Findings on Marlin and Sailfish in Costa Rica

Satellite tracking research is providing new insight into how marlin and sailfish move through the Pacific Ocean and recover after being caught and released,...

Heavy Storms Could Drop Nearly 3 Inches of Rain on Costa Rica Today

Short, intense downpours, thunderstorms and gusts up to 80 km/h are forecast for the Central Valley, the Caribbean and the northern zone Friday afternoon.

Dollar Expected to Keep Falling in Costa Rica After Record Low of 446 Colones

The dollar hit a record low of 446.10 colones and analysts expect it to keep falling until year-end. Here's why.

Costa Rica Has Never Beaten Argentina and Gets Another Shot Tuesday in Córdoba

Costa Rica faces a post-Messi Argentina Tuesday in Córdoba at 5 p.m., missing Keylor Navas and two defenders. Kickoff, TV channels and what to watch.

Killers of Costa Rica Journalist May Have Had Help Tracking Him, OIJ Says

The OIJ says the gunmen who killed journalist Camilo Rodríguez knew his vehicle and may have had accomplices tracking him. Agents raided his home and seized devices as prosecutors review the people he named online.

Shakira Returns to Costa Rica in 2027 After More Than 15 Years

Shakira plans a January 31, 2027 show at Costa Rica's National Stadium, her first here since 2011.

Flying Between Costa Rica and the US Today? Cancellations Have Dropped Sharply

Monday US flight cancellations fell below 150 after the weekend ground stop. Check these things before you fly to or from Costa Rica.
Loading…

Latest News from Costa Rica

Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Car Rentals
Costa Rica Travel Insurance
Costa Rica Travel