Costa Rica Coffee Guide

Court Orders Gov’t to Grab Playa Grande Land

May 16, 2008

Costa Rica’s highest court has ordered the Environment and Energy Ministry to begin expropriating privately owned property “immediately” inside Las Baulas National Marine Park, in the northwestern province of Guanacaste.

The Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court warned in its ruling that if Environment Minister Roberto Dobles does not carry out the ruling, he could face sanctions.

The ministry has been criticized for stalling on the expropriation orders.

Earlier this year, the environmental group Leatherback Trust cancelled a 2004 agreement with the ministry to help fund the expropriations, which could cost more than $800 million. The group had already reportedly raised at least $8 million.

In a strongly worded letter, the organization’s president, James Spotila, accused the ministry of dragging its feet.

The ministry and landowners are at odds over the value of the property, with government appraisals ranging from $50 per square meter up to $800, while landowners are demanding nothing less than $1,200 (TT, Oct. 19).

The park, just north of Tamarindo, was created by decree in 1991 and then by law in 1995. However, a dispute over the interpretation of the language of the law led to drawn-out legal battles between the property owners, who believe the park includes only the beach and marine territory, and environmentalists, who insist it includes a terrestrial portion.

In a binding 2005 ruling, the Attorney General’s Office sided with the environmentalists, declaring the land owned by the mostly foreign investors is part of the national park and requiring it be expropriated.

The park is of particular importance to the critically endangered leatherback sea turtle, whose numbers have plummeted more than 90% during the past 20 years (TT, April 13, 2007).

Playa Grande ranks as the most important nesting beach in Costa Rica and one of the five most important in the world.

Randall Arauz, of the Marine Turtle Restoration Program (PRETOMA), an environmental group that has long been fighting for the expropriations, said the court’s recent ruling is encouraging.

“At least there is one government institution we can go to,” he said.

When asked about how the government could pay for the expropriations, Arauz said he believed land values should be appraised at their worth when the park was created.

“Anyone who bought after 1991 did so knowing that it was a national park. The land already had restrictions,” he said.

Dobles could not be reached for comment because he was in the United States this week, said an environment ministry spokesman.

 

You may be interested

Some 34 million jobs lost in Latin America due to pandemic
Business
3339 views
Business
3339 views

Some 34 million jobs lost in Latin America due to pandemic

Carlos MANDUJANO / AFP - September 30, 2020

The two aspirers for the presidency of Costa Rica, the evangelical preacher Fabricio Alvarado and the former minister Carlos Alvarado, reach the closing of the electoral campaign for April 1st with a technical draw, according to a poll disclosed this Friday.

CureVac launches second stage of vaccine clinical trials in Peru and Panama
News
21360 views
News
21360 views

CureVac launches second stage of vaccine clinical trials in Peru and Panama

AFP - September 30, 2020

The German pharmaceutical company CureVac announced that it has started Phase 2 clinical trials of its experimental vaccine against Covid-19,…

Costa Rica mired in difficult internal negotiations regarding agreement with IMF
Costa Rica
902 views
Costa Rica
902 views

Costa Rica mired in difficult internal negotiations regarding agreement with IMF

Marco SIBAJA / AFP - September 30, 2020

Costa Rica is immersed in difficult internal negotiations as it seeks an agreement with the International Monetary Fund (IMF) to…