HomeArchiveCAFTA Bill Violates Constitution

CAFTA Bill Violates Constitution

A bill to crack down on intellectual property violations is unconstitutional, the Supreme Court said earlier this month in a ruling that sets back President Oscar Arias’ free-trade agenda.

The bill, which calls for hefty fines or prison terms for copyright, trademark and patent violations, was intended to put Costa Rica in compliance with the Central American Free-Trade Agreement with the United States (CAFTA).

The Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court (Sala IV) said the punishment for displaying copyrighted works without the author’s permission – a $2,700 to $227,000 fine or a two-month to six-year prison term, depending on the work’s value – is disproportional and excessive.

Another problematic clause would have allowed authorities to seize pirated or falsified material and other evidence related  to the crime. That violates a constitutionalmandate that private documents and communication are “inviolable,” justices said.

The ruling could delay the bill’s passage by several months. Lawmakers must further debate the bill and hold a second vote. The opposition Citizen Action Party (PAC) could then challenge the bill again before the Sala IV, which takes about a month to reach a decision.

The bill is one of 12 required, in some form, to enter CAFTA before an Oct. 1 deadline. Six have become law.

The Sala IV has thus far found fault with one other CAFTA bill, the one that would lift a state telecommunications monopoly. Due to a technical glitch, lawmakers held a vote without debating motions proposed by PAC lawmaker Leda Zamora. They must now debate the bill further.

 

Trending Now

US Airline Seats to Costa Rica Fall 14% as Fares Climb

Scheduled US airline seats to Costa Rica are projected to fall 14% through March, with San José down 20%, Liberia down 3% and fares up as much as 45%.

Gusts Up to 80 km/h Hit Costa Rica’s Mountains as a Windy, Dry Week Begins

Gusts up to 80 km/h (50 mph) are forecast in Costa Rica's mountains and La Cruz as trade winds settle in for the week.

Should You Buy Travel Insurance for Costa Rica After the US Ground Stop?

Airlines refund canceled flights but not stranded hotels and meals. When travel insurance pays, and what to check.

Guided Hikes in Costa Rica Would Need ICT Licenses and Insurance Under New Bill

Companies that sell or lead guided hikes in Costa Rica would need a license from the Costa Rican Tourism Institute (ICT) and insurance covering...

DEA Traced Costa Rica’s First Female Extradition Case to a 2-Ton Jungle Lab

How the DEA built the Arizona case behind Costa Rica's first female extradition case.

Gunmen Kill Costa Rican Journalist Camilo Rodríguez on Route 32 in Heredia

Prosecutors will examine whether earlier death threats are linked to the killing, which the attorney general called the third murder of a journalist in Costa Rica.

Masks Are Back at Some Costa Rica Hospitals. Here’s Where You Need One

Several Costa Rica public hospitals require masks again as respiratory cases rise. See where you need one before your visit.

Salvadoran Troops Turn Haiti National Stadium Into Base After Retaking It From Gangs

Salvadoran and Haitian forces retook Port-au-Prince's Sylvio Cator stadium from gangs. Bukele says it will now serve as a base for the next push.

US Ground Stop Canceled 15 Costa Rica Flights. Here’s What to Expect Today

Updated Saturday afternoon with the cause of the outage, Saturday's cancellations and when flights should be back to normal. The nationwide US ground stop that...
Loading…

Latest News from Costa Rica

Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Car Rentals
Costa Rica Travel Insurance
Costa Rica Travel