HomeArchiveCAFTA Bill Violates Constitution

CAFTA Bill Violates Constitution

A bill to crack down on intellectual property violations is unconstitutional, the Supreme Court said earlier this month in a ruling that sets back President Oscar Arias’ free-trade agenda.

The bill, which calls for hefty fines or prison terms for copyright, trademark and patent violations, was intended to put Costa Rica in compliance with the Central American Free-Trade Agreement with the United States (CAFTA).

The Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court (Sala IV) said the punishment for displaying copyrighted works without the author’s permission – a $2,700 to $227,000 fine or a two-month to six-year prison term, depending on the work’s value – is disproportional and excessive.

Another problematic clause would have allowed authorities to seize pirated or falsified material and other evidence related  to the crime. That violates a constitutionalmandate that private documents and communication are “inviolable,” justices said.

The ruling could delay the bill’s passage by several months. Lawmakers must further debate the bill and hold a second vote. The opposition Citizen Action Party (PAC) could then challenge the bill again before the Sala IV, which takes about a month to reach a decision.

The bill is one of 12 required, in some form, to enter CAFTA before an Oct. 1 deadline. Six have become law.

The Sala IV has thus far found fault with one other CAFTA bill, the one that would lift a state telecommunications monopoly. Due to a technical glitch, lawmakers held a vote without debating motions proposed by PAC lawmaker Leda Zamora. They must now debate the bill further.

 

Trending Now

US Loses Measles-Free Status After 26 Years. What It Means for Costa Rica Travel

The US lost its measles-free status after 26 years. What it means if you fly from Costa Rica, and where to get a booster.

Heavy Storms Could Drop Nearly 3 Inches of Rain on Costa Rica Today

Short, intense downpours, thunderstorms and gusts up to 80 km/h are forecast for the Central Valley, the Caribbean and the northern zone Friday afternoon.

Costa Rica’s Top Prosecutor May Face Lawmakers Over Slain Journalist’s Threat Complaints

Costa Rica's ruling party wants the top prosecutor and its acting chief of judicial police to explain to lawmakers how they handled the threat...

Costa Rica Moves to Demolish Narco Airstrips Without a Conviction

A Costa Rica bill would let authorities destroy clandestine airstrips without a final ruling and freeze land linked to them. It now heads to a floor vote.

Banks and Businesses in Costa Rica Must Accept Digital ID Starting January

Starting January 1, 2027, banks, government agencies, businesses and other institutions in Costa Rica will be required to accept the Costa Rican Digital Identity...

San José’s Festival de la Luz Swaps Floats for 10 Giant Balloons This Year

San José's Festival de la Luz is December 12, with no floats this year. See the new route, balloon lineup, lights switch-on date and district festivals.

Flying Between Costa Rica and the US Today? Cancellations Have Dropped Sharply

Monday US flight cancellations fell below 150 after the weekend ground stop. Check these things before you fly to or from Costa Rica.

Costa Rica Banks Pay as Little as 436 Colones per Dollar – Here’s How to Get More

With the dollar at a record low, Costa Rica banks are paying 436 to 440 colones per dollar. Here is how to compare rates and avoid costly conversions.

Costa Rica Wildlife Cameras Catch Heron Catfish Hunts and an Ocelot Latrine

My camera traps continue to provide me with brief glimpses into the hidden lives of Costa Rica’s wild animals. Today we look at a...
Loading…

Latest News from Costa Rica

Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Car Rentals
Costa Rica Travel Insurance
Costa Rica Travel