• Costa Rica Coffee Guide

The Hague Court: Territory disputed with Nicaragua belongs to Costa Rica

December 16, 2015

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) on Wednesday recognized Costa Rica’s sovereignty over a 2.5-square-kilometer disputed territory on the border with Nicaragua, one of the main claims fought over by the two countries at The Hague-based court.

“The sovereignty over the disputed territory belongs to Costa Rica,” Justice Ronny Abraham said. The justice said the artificial canal opened by Nicaragua in 2010 through Isla Calero, also called Isla Portillos or Harbour Head Island, was within Costa Rican territory and not part of the common border between the two countries.

Most of the court ruling favored Costa Rica in the five-year dispute between the neighboring countries. Justices unanimously found that Nicaragua violated Costa Rican territory by invading Isla Calero with military personnel, and by dredging canals in Costa Rican territory and by violating Costa Rica’s navigation rights on the San Juan River, a natural border between the two countries.

Find more background on the dispute here

Nicaragua also was ordered to compensate Costa Rica for damage caused to its territory.

The court dismissed Nicaragua’s complaint that the construction of a 160-kilometer road that runs parallel to the San Juan River caused irreparable damage to the river. Justices, however, found that Costa Rica had violated Nicaragua’s rights by failing to conduct an environmental impact study prior to construction of the road.

President Luis Guillermo Solís said the ICJ’s ruling absolutely confirmed Costa Rica’s rights on the dispute.

“It’s a great victory for the country, for our people. The result was not a coincidence, it’s the result of the hard work of our legal team,” he said.

Foreign Minister Manuel González at a press conference in Casa Presidencial said officials are pleased with the court’s analysis of the case and its ruling, saying they strengthen hope in international law to solve differences between countries.

Former President Laura Chinchilla also addressed the ruling at a press conference saying she was very happy that the ruling was overwhelmingly in favor of Costa Rica.

Both countries had previously accepted to abide by the court’s decision.

Follow The Tico Times for updates

Below is a timeline of events in the Costa Rica–Nicaragua border dispute: 

You may be interested

Who was Juan Santamaría? Five (debated) things you should know
Juan Santamaría Day
5033 views
Juan Santamaría Day
5033 views

Who was Juan Santamaría? Five (debated) things you should know

JILL REPLOGLE - April 12, 2021

A version of this story first ran in 2015. Costa Rica feted its first and most-loved national hero, Juan Santamaría, on…

Saprissa equals longest winless streak in 35 years
Soccer
1523 views
Soccer
1523 views

Saprissa equals longest winless streak in 35 years

The Tico Times - April 12, 2021

Deportivo Saprissa drew 1-1 with Pérez Zeledón and reached eight consecutive games without a win in the Clausura 2021 soccer…

Costa Rica relocation/retirement guide book releases its 19th edition
News
8 views
News
8 views

Costa Rica relocation/retirement guide book releases its 19th edition

Tico Times - April 11, 2021

Long time Costa Rica citizen and Tico Times columnist, Christopher Howard, releases the 19th edition of his popular relocation/retirement guide Over…