HomeArchiveStudy: U.S. immigration reform would cost $6.3 trillion

Study: U.S. immigration reform would cost $6.3 trillion

WASHINGTON, D.C. – A U.S. political battle raged Monday over the cost of Senate-proposed immigration reform, with a conservative think-tank warning the plan to legalize 11 million undocumented workers would soar to $6.3 trillion.

The Heritage Foundation, in a report released shortly before amendments are proposed to the bipartisan bill, said legalized immigrants’ costs such as Social Security, Medicaid health care for the poor, and unemployment insurance would stack up dramatically faster than many U.S. lawmakers would realize.

The report is certain to galvanize some conservatives in Congress who are opposed to the plan, seen as the most ambitious immigration reform effort in a generation and which was rolled out last month by a “Gang of Eight” senators – four Democrats and four Republicans.

U.S. President Barack Obama envisions immigration reform as a major and viable second-term accomplishment, after Republicans who lost last November’s election said it was crucial to reach out to minority communities such as Hispanics, the largest beneficiaries of any immigration deal.

But Heritage said the millions of immigrants who would be legalized through “amnesty” would generate massive fiscal deficits over the long term, driven in large part by extra pressures on health care for low-income Americans, public education and services like police, fire and roads.

The bill creates a path to citizenship for the estimated 11.5 million people living in the country illegally, but under certain conditions like tighter border enforcement and after a 13-year wait, during which time they will not be entitled to government aid.

The foundation’s study argued that while immigrants currently in the U.S. illegally would start to pay taxes once they register legally, when they become citizens they will be net recipients of government funds.

It said they would receive those benefits for five decades, if their retirement pension is included, with their cost to government coffers pegged at $9.4 trillion, while they will pay just $3.1 trillion in taxes.

“No sensible thinking person would read this study and conclude that, over 50 years, that it could possibly have a positive economic impact,” Heritage Foundation President Jim DeMint, a Republican former senator, said at a press conference.

Report co-author Robert Rector warned that the costs jump to about $160 billion per year about 35 years from today, when the bulk of the group reaches retirement age.

But pro-reformers immediately assailed the Heritage plan as ignoring the prospect that millions of immigrants would become substantial contributors to the nation’s economic prosperity.

Doug Holtz-Eakin, former director of the Congressional Budget Office who now heads the American Action Forum, said the Heritage Foundation report did “mislead people about the genuine budgetary impact” of immigration reform.

“The notion that 50 years from now all 12 million who are here illegally will be collecting full benefits is a vast overstatement,” he told reporters, adding that under Heritage’s formula, the immigrant experience begins and ends in poverty.

“There’s no American dream, there’s no upward mobility for anyone” according to Heritage, Holtz-Eakin said.

The report more than doubles the cost estimated in a 2007 Heritage study, which said a Senate plan for immigration amnesty being considered that year – but which ultimately failed – would cost a net $2.6 trillion.

Trending Now

Horacio Zeballos and Marcel Granollers Make Winning Start at ATP Finals

Argentina's Horacio Zeballos and Spanish partner Marcel Granollers opened their ATP Finals campaign with a convincing victory Monday, defeating Italy's Simone Bolelli and Andrea...

Gunmen Kill Costa Rican Journalist Camilo Rodríguez on Route 32 in Heredia

Prosecutors will examine whether earlier death threats are linked to the killing, which the attorney general called the third murder of a journalist in Costa Rica.

Dollar Falls to a Record Low of 446 Colones in Costa Rica

The dollar closed at an average of 446.10 colones on Monex on Friday, its weakest level since the platform opened in 2006 and the eighth straight daily decline.

Marino Ballena Closes Piñuela Entrance for Six Months, Whale Tail Still Open

Marino Ballena's Piñuela sector is closed for six months. Here's which entrances are still open.

Flying Between Costa Rica and the US Today? Cancellations Have Dropped Sharply

Monday US flight cancellations fell below 150 after the weekend ground stop. Check these things before you fly to or from Costa Rica.

Luisa Stefani Moves Closer to WTA Finals Semifinals After Dramatic Comeback

Brazil's Luisa Stefani and Canadian partner Gabriela Dabrowski moved closer to the WTA Finals doubles semifinals Wednesday after producing a dramatic comeback to defeat...

The Perfect Family Beach Day at Playa Carrillo, Costa Rica

This is between me and you. Don’t tell anybody else. We don’t want too many people overcrowding the places I’m about to tell you...

Microsoft Global Outage Disrupts Outlook, Teams and Health Services Worldwide

Microsoft’s global outage ran into a second day Friday. Outlook email is still failing for many users, and parts of Teams, Copilot and other...

Salvadoran Troops Turn Haiti National Stadium Into Base After Retaking It From Gangs

Salvadoran and Haitian forces retook Port-au-Prince's Sylvio Cator stadium from gangs. Bukele says it will now serve as a base for the next push.
Loading…

Latest News from Costa Rica

Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Car Rentals
Costa Rica Travel Insurance
Costa Rica Travel