HomeNewsCosta RicaCourt rejects tax reform and asks legislators to eliminate four points

Court rejects tax reform and asks legislators to eliminate four points

Costa Rica’s Plenary Court has rejected the proposed tax reform bill in its current state and asked the members of the Legislative Assembly to correct four points of the initiative, which, in the opinion of the magistrates, affect the independence and operation of the judicial system.

This was decided after 11 of 16 justices voted in favor of this proposal.

The justices requested that the assembly eliminate the Planning Ministry’s oversight of public employment in the Judiciary Branch, as well as Civil Service review of judicial officials’ job performance.

Third, justices objected to measures that would reduce resources available for witness protection programs and the fight against organized crime

Finally, justices requested that the legislators eliminate salary modifications and requested that they take into consideration “the particularities” of the Judicial Power and the demands of its posts, such as on-call officers who must be available to work when necessary.

If legislators make these changes, the Court will give the go-ahead to the project and it can be approved by a simple majority in second debate. Otherwise, legislators will need a two-thirds majority of 38 votes to overrule the court’s objections.

Tax reform bill passes first debate; strike will continue

Tax solidarity vs. judicial independence

The court’s session began with the presentation of the criterion of the Legal Directorate, overseen by Rodrigo Campos. He explained the main effects the project would have, the perceived interference of the Planning Ministry in the evaluation of performance, and the establishment of the fiscal rule for granting of resources.

Iris Rocío Rojas, a judge from the Supreme Court’s Civil and Administrative Law Branch,  argued that the bill does not affect the independence of the Judiciary and that the triggers for spending must be attacked. In addition, she defended the imposition of a fiscal rule.

“The fiscal rule is an adequate instrument to adjust current spending to GDP,” she said. “Nothing justifies growth without resources in institutions that depend on the budget and lack their own resources.

“While there’s extreme poverty in this country, I do not have any problem with a person who directs public finances and gives that money to school canteens or public defenders. The people elected to govern have the legitimacy to do so,” Rojas said.

For his part, the alternate judge of the Penal Branch of the Supreme Court, Jaime Robleto, affirmed there is a public perception that the Judicial Power is the culprit of the fiscal crisis. However, he claimed he feels a “moral obligation” to support the tax reform.

“We all have to sacrifice ourselves, and those who earn more, sacrifice even more,” the judge said.

The president of the Court, Fernando Cruz, reaffirmed his opposition and announced he will reject supplemental pay from the rubro de índice general (in his case, the equivalent of ₡1.4 million, or approximately $2,350), an incentive approved in 2008 that applies to 46 high-ranking officials in the judicial branch.

Currently, Judge Cruz earns a net salary of ₡6.3 million (about $10,600). Starting next month, the net salary of the president of the Court will be ₡4.9 million (about $8,250).

President is safe after confrontation with protesters

“Do not say that my position on the reform is to defend my privileges,” said the constitutional judge, who says he made the decision in order to have moral authority in his position.

The magistrate, who will be inhibited in a possible legislatively consultation to the Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court, affirmed that “it seems that the Judicial Power now has to solve poverty.

“Well, maybe it’s another function that they want to give us. Are we, the middle class, going to solve the country’s poverty?” Cruz said.

Justice Carmen María Escoto spoke against the project. She said that if legislators modify the power of the Planning Ministry to evaluate judicial officials, she would vote in favor.

The magistrate of Supreme the Court’s Civil and Administrative Law Branch, William Molinari, reiterated his opposition to the tax reform. He presented a report in September based on a previous version of the bill in which he alleged that it would negatively affect the Judicial Power.

“Because of the content of the forms and the way in which they have been written, it gives a thousand ways to affect the Judiciary. This can directly affect the appointment of judges, evaluation of prosecutors and prosecutors, among other things,” Molinari said.


Semanario Universidad Logo

This story was prepared for Semanario Universidad and translated and adapted for The Tico Times. Read the original report here.

Trending Now

Gusts Up to 80 km/h Hit Costa Rica’s Mountains as a Windy, Dry Week Begins

Gusts up to 80 km/h (50 mph) are forecast in Costa Rica's mountains and La Cruz as trade winds settle in for the week.

Should You Buy Travel Insurance for Costa Rica After the US Ground Stop?

Airlines refund canceled flights but not stranded hotels and meals. When travel insurance pays, and what to check.

US Airline Seats to Costa Rica Fall 14% as Fares Climb

Scheduled US airline seats to Costa Rica are projected to fall 14% through March, with San José down 20%, Liberia down 3% and fares up as much as 45%.

Costa Rica Mourns Actor and TV Host Leonardo Perucci, Dead at 87

Leonardo Perucci, the Chilean-born actor and host of the 1980s TV hit Fantástico, died Tuesday at 87 after more than four decades on Costa Rican stages and screens.

Women in Costa Rica Can Now Choose a Female Uber Driver

Women in Costa Rica can now request a female Uber driver. Here is how Uber Mujeres works.

The Local Pharmacy and the Surprises of Costa Rica Life

Your local neighborhood pharmacy is a one-stop-for-all-your-health-needs institution. Last year, a law passed requiring a doctor’s prescription for many types of antibiotics and other...

Pura Vida: The Dream, the Reality and Everything in Between

Is Costa Rica's famous way of life everything we imagine it to be? Or is the real meaning of Pura Vida something we only...

El Niño Could Leave 306,000 People in Costa Rica Short of Water

More than 306,000 people in Costa Rica could face problems getting drinking water as the strongest El Niño on record dries us out, according...

Prosecutors Say They Found Signs of Abuse at Costa Rica’s New Megaprison

Costa Rica's attorney general says prosecutors found signs of possible torture at the CACCO megaprison. The Justice Ministry called the visit a show.
Loading…

Latest News from Costa Rica

Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Car Rentals
Costa Rica Travel Insurance
Costa Rica Travel