HomeArchiveUnions Question Funding for Private Schools

Unions Question Funding for Private Schools

Sending his children to private school is a decision that José Hernán Acuña doesn’t regret.

In his two decades as a parent of students at Colegio Madre del Divino Pastor in Guadalupe, Acuña has seen the sons and daughters of poor and middle class families become engineers, doctors and professors.

He has watched test scores come back registering as some of the highest in the district. And he has celebrated as his four children avoided the violence that has plagued nearby public schools.

Acuña is so impressed with the achievements of Costa Rican private schools that he mused during an interview this week, “There isn’t one thing they do wrong.”

Though the accomplishments of private schools are as stark to him as a bright red apple on a teacher’s desk, he is watching a movement unfold that could significantly change or even close some private schools.

For more than 35 years, many of these schools in Costa Rica have been sustained by government funding. Although donations and tuition contribute to administrative costs, building maintenance and other capital expenditures, the Costa Rican government has long paid teacher salaries.

Legislators are currently considering a bill that would solidify this funding by law. However, they have received unexpected opposition from several education unions.

“How can we take resources from public education, that already has many needs, in order to finance private business?” asked Gilberth Díaz, president of the Education Workers Union (SEC). “This promotes inequality between the poor and the rich.”

The Education Ministry allocates more than ¢7 billion (roughly $12 million) to 90 of the country’s private schools each year.

These funds help lower operating costs and pay teacher salaries, thereby reducing student tuition. The ministry estimates that approximately 20,900 students benefit indirectly through the government allocations.

For schools like the Colegio Madre del Divino Pastor, where 90 percent of the students have reduced tuitions or full scholarships, the government subsidy is essential to the school’s existence.

“Most students cannot pay for private school,” Acuña said, estimating that students now pay between ¢22,000 and ¢23,000 ($40) per month to attend these schools. He said that without government funding that cost would be much higher.

“As public education has deteriorated over the past two decades,” Acuña said, “I don’t understand why they want to eliminate (private school funding).”

The move to make the ¢7 billion governmental allocation to private schools law stemmed from a finding by the Comptroller General’s Office, which issued a report in 2003 saying that such funding lacked adequate controls and supervision.

The Education Ministry responded in 2006 with a regulation designed to monitor the allocation. It, however, was stalled in the Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court (Sala IV) on a legal technicality.

Concerned that the newly proposed bill would deflect much-needed funds from public education, major unions are lobbying legislators to reject it.

“Our responsibility is to make sure that public education is not affected and is not commercialized,” Díaz said, who is joined in his opposition by the National Association of Educators (ANDE). Díaz warned of what he considers a danger in using public resources to finance private endeavors.

Libertarian Mario Quirós, a staunch advocate of the bill and continued state support of private schools, responded, “If you have a garden with a grand, flowering tree in the backyard, why would you cut it down? This system has flourished for (35 years), why would you eliminate it? It’s been another way to help the state educate its children.”

The bill, which was languishing on the sidelines for months after it was proposed in 2007, rose to the top of the legislative agenda when dozens of Catholic school parents and teachers lobbied at the Legislative Assembly in mid-April. The bill is scheduled for renewed discussion on Tuesday, May 19.

Officials with the Education Ministry are hesitant to endorse the proposal because they say it provides no parameters to determine which institutions may benefit from the state subsidy. Also, ministry officials say it does not provide a mechanism for monitoring how private institutions use state funds.

“We acknowledge that centers deserve and need this state help,” said Silvia Víquez, administrative vice president with the Education Ministry, in a statement. However, the ministry believes that the bill restores abuses in the handling of funding that the ministry had already eliminated.

One of the most serious faults with the proposed law, according to Diaz, is that it establishes a double standard, offering funding to private schools with no strings attached.

“In Costa Rica, there are only two types of education: public and private,” Diaz said. “The private institutions can choose their students and their professors (unlike public schools), which makes this a situation of inequality.”

“Yet, the opportunity to choose students and teachers is what sets these private schools apart,” Acuña said. “Because of their selectivity, ability to self-govern and the opportunity to operate as a separate entity, they have been successful.”

“That is the difference of excellence,” he said. “We lose those things, we become just another public school.”

 

Trending Now

Have a US Visa Appointment Wednesday? The Embassy Will Be Closed

The US Embassy and visa section in San José close Nov. 11 for Veterans Day and reopen Thursday.

Monteverde Went From 25 Dry Days a Year to Nearly 120, BBC Reports

Costa Rica's best known cloud forest is in the international spotlight this week after the BBC published a lengthy feature on Monteverde, reporting that...

Gunmen Kill Costa Rican Journalist Camilo Rodríguez on Route 32 in Heredia

Prosecutors will examine whether earlier death threats are linked to the killing, which the attorney general called the third murder of a journalist in Costa Rica.

Costa Rica Hemp Permits Are Free for Six Years, but Now You Must Apply Online

If you want to grow hemp or medical cannabis legally in Costa Rica, there is now only one way to apply. Since November 12,...

Costa Rica Moves to Fire 36 Finance Ministry Workers Over Mouse-Jiggler App

Costa Rica's Finance Ministry is still working to fire 36 employees accused of installing a mouse-jiggler program to make it look as if they...

Flying Between Costa Rica and the US Today? Cancellations Have Dropped Sharply

Monday US flight cancellations fell below 150 after the weekend ground stop. Check these things before you fly to or from Costa Rica.

Costa Rica President Says Jailed Gang Members Ordered Her Killing

President Laura Fernández said Monday that prison intelligence reports show gang members behind bars have ordered her assassination.

A Quiet Island Escape in Costa Rica’s Gulf of Nicoya

A three-hour journey and a short boat ride from my home in Costa Rica took me somewhere that felt much farther away. Isla Jesusita...

Santa Cruz, Home to Tamarindo, Leads Guanacaste in Murders and Car Break-Ins

Santa Cruz has 22 of Guanacaste's 75 homicides this year, with Tamarindo on top. OIJ detained 10, including two police officers.
Loading…

Latest News from Costa Rica

Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Car Rentals
Costa Rica Travel Insurance
Costa Rica Travel