• Costa Rica Coffee Guide

What happened to Carla Stefaniak? Few new details in case

April 29, 2019

Carla Stefaniak was visiting Costa Rica from the United States last November when she went missing.

In a case that quickly garnered international attention, authorities soon found Stefaniak’s body near the San Antonio of Escazú property she had rented through Airbnb. An autopsy revealed she had died of stab wounds to the neck and extremities, as well as a strong blow to the head.

Judicial Investigation Police (OIJ) and the Public Security Ministry (MSP) detained a security guard, surname Espinoza Martinez, as a suspect in the death.

In late December, Stefaniak’s family sued Airbnb and Villa Buena Vista. ABC News shared part of the lawsuit, which accused the property owners of negligence. 

“Defendants, AIRBNB and VILLA BUENA VISTA, negligently failed to perform any kind of background check or otherwise take any measures to determine whether Martinez was fit for the officiality and authority and power and control provided to him,” the lawsuit states.

“The harm to Stefaniak caused by MARTINEZ was a foreseeable and well-known hazard of the industry.”

The property in which Carla Stefaniak, a tourist from the United States, was renting an apartment through Airbnb. Duncan Anderson / The Tico Times

Earlier this month, the Stefaniaks’ attorney, Joseph Rivera, spoke with Teletica and provided further updates on the case. He said the family believes more people were involved in Stefaniak’s death, citing the distance her body was moved and alleging the room was cleaned after her death.

“We maintain a hypothesis that between five and seven people [were involved],” Rivera told Teletica. “Because for us, it’s difficult for a rigid body — a dead body — to be moved to where they found the body.”

OIJ’s investigation of the case remains ongoing. The organization has not named additional suspects in the crime other than Espinoza Martinez, whom OIJ said is a Nicaraguan citizen who was in the country illegally.

“We are waiting for more information from OIJ,” Rivera said.

Authorities are still trying to match DNA samples from blood found under Stefaniak’s fingernails, according to Teletica.

“In this moment, the investigation remains open,” Marco Carrión, chief of OIJ’s homicide department, said. “We are looking for whatever element, whatever details will help us finalize the investigative phase.

“At the moment, what we have established is a single person was responsible.”

Stefaniak’s family held a celebration of life for Carla on Jan. 26. Via their Facebook page, Finding Carla, they have asked others to “keep the pressure” on OIJ to prevent the case from being forgotten.

“This is a complex case, and it’s a difficult case,”  Walter Espinoza, the Director General of the OIJ, said in December. “The resolution of this case is very important for the country, for the victim’s family, and for society as a whole.”



You may be interested

El Salvador donates painkillers to Costa Rica for Covid-19 patients
Costa Rica
1 views
Costa Rica
1 views

El Salvador donates painkillers to Costa Rica for Covid-19 patients

The Tico Times - April 22, 2021

El Salvador donated 10,000 injections of an analgesic to Costa Rica used in the treatment of patients admitted to intensive…

2021 LatAm growth won’t offset pandemic economic decline: UN
Latin America
8 views
Latin America
8 views

2021 LatAm growth won’t offset pandemic economic decline: UN

AFP - April 21, 2021

Projected economic growth in Latin America and the Caribbean in 2021 will not offset 2020 losses caused by the coronavirus…

Tourists have high perception of Costa Rica during Covid, survey says
Costa Rica
5 views
Costa Rica
5 views

Tourists have high perception of Costa Rica during Covid, survey says

The Tico Times - April 21, 2021

A survey of tourism professionals in Spain has recognized Costa Rica among the best-perceived international destinations during the pandemic. The…