Costa Rica Coffee Guide

Prosecutor gives up on La Penca bombing case

March 11, 2011

Whoever was responsible for planting the bomb that killed seven people and left 21 wounded at a press conference 26 years ago at La Penca likely got away with it.

Any further official investigation on the attack that took place in a small Nicaraguan border community will officially lead nowhere, since Costa Rican authorities admit their inability to collect enough evidence to track down the bomber or any of the involved suspects, according to a letter sent last December by Costa Rica’s chief public prosecutor, Jorge Chavarría, to members of the Costa Rican Journalists Association (CRJA).

Now CRJA members say they will no longer appeal to Costa Rican authorities to solve the case. Instead, they plan on pushing forward a claim filed in 2005 with the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (ICHR). That case charges the Costa Rica government with failing to take proper measures to guarantee prompt and effective justice for La Penca’s victims.

If enough evidence is gathered that proves Costa Rican authorities were negligent, then the ICHR will recommend the case to the Inter-American Court of Human Rights, where a final ruling will be issued.

The bombing happened on May 30, 1984, and is considered to be one of the darkest chapters in the history of Costa Rican journalism.

That day journalists from several news agencies attended a press conference held by Edén Pastora, the legendary guerrilla leader known as “Comandante Cero,” who years after a daring 1978 Sandinista takeover of Nicaragua’s congressional National Palace became a U.S.-sponsored rebel leader seeking to oust Daniel Ortega’s government in Nicaragua.

During the ill-fated press trip, journalists departed from Costa Rica to an undisclosed destination, and then on to a small hut in La Penca where the conference with Pastora was to be held. The press conference started at 7:15 p.m., and a few minutes later a deadly blast took the lives of several attendees, including Tico Times reporter Linda Frazier.  

Over the years, several theories emerged about the attack’s perpetrator, or perpetrators. The most widely believed theory is that Roberto Vital Gaguine, an Argentine leftist who disguised himself as a Danish photographer named Peer Anker Hansen, planted the bomb.

Last year Peter Torbiornsson, a Swedish journalist injured in the massacre, told Costa Rican authorities that Tomás Borges, Nicaragua’s interior minister at the time, allegedly ordered Pastora’s execution, to take place during the press conference. 

But that allegation may never be confirmed or proven false, according to Chavarría’s letter, which he sent to the CRJA on Dec. 23, 2010.

TT04 LA PENCA 7

Terror at La Penca: Red Cross members, carry a victim to hospital facilities in Ciudad Quesada, in the northern province of Alajuela. It took medics at least four hours to arrive to the site of the bombing.

Photos courtesy of Costa Rica Journalists Association

“There are no real possibilities of any further progress in this case in the near future, because the legal identity of the perpetrator has not been clearly established,” Chavarría wrote.

“It’s not right if nothing happens [with the investigation]. That’s like saying that the victims’ lives don’t mean anything,” said journalist Gilberto López, one of the survivors. 

Like other survivors of the attack, López is convinced that no one will ever be prosecuted in the case. But if the case proceeds to the human rights court and the Costa Rican government is found to be negligent, members of the CRJA say they will sue the government.

“The veil of impunity will be cast over this case for centuries to come, but it is important to take this to international forums and provide victims with some sense of justice, even if it’s only monetary compensation,” said Nelson Murillo, a former journalist forced to retire because of his injuries.

You may be interested

IMF predicts ‘partial and uneven’ recovery in Latin America due to Covid-19
Costa Rica
823 views
Costa Rica
823 views

IMF predicts ‘partial and uneven’ recovery in Latin America due to Covid-19

AFP and The Tico Times - September 24, 2020

The International Monetary Fund foresees a "partial and uneven" recovery in Latin America after the Covid-19 crisis, and it anticipates…

Costa Rica coronavirus updates for Wednesday, September 23
Costa Rica
5488 views
Costa Rica
5488 views

Costa Rica coronavirus updates for Wednesday, September 23

Alejandro Zúñiga - September 23, 2020

Costa Rica announced 21 new coronavirus-related deaths over the last day for a total of 781, according to official data…

Costa Rica’s Playa Hermosa named as World Surfing Reserve
Costa Rica
11831 views
Costa Rica
11831 views

Costa Rica’s Playa Hermosa named as World Surfing Reserve

Alejandro Zúñiga - September 23, 2020

Save The Waves Coalition has named Playa Hermosa in Garabito, Puntarenas as a World Surfing Reserve (WSR), the non-profit announced…