No menu items!

COSTA RICA'S LEADING ENGLISH LANGUAGE NEWSPAPER

HomeArchiveElectoral System Sputters as More Claims of Fraud Surface

Electoral System Sputters as More Claims of Fraud Surface

As allegations of vote fraud and other irregular behavior continue to surface following the March 7 regional elections in the North and South Atlantic Autonomous Regions (RAAN and RAAS, respectively), Roberto Courtney, executive director of electoral watchdog group Ethics and Transparency, insists the simmering electoral scandal is further proof that Nicaragua has “the worst and least credible electoral system in all of Latin America.”

Conducting elections, Courtney said, “Is not like playing baseball, where you can go three for 10 and make the Hall of Fame. It’s more like landing a plane: you have to do it safely every time.”

But following the highly disputed 2008 municipal elections, which were dubbed the “most documented case of electoral fraud in Latin American history,” Courtney said “the burden of proof has shifted” and Nicaraguans can no longer presume that elections will be conducted fairly here, especially when the electoral authorities continue to prevent implementation of basic safeguards for transparency.

For example, despite the widespread cries of fraud following the 2008 elections, which were conducted without any credible outside observers, the Supreme Electoral Council (CSE) again ignored requests from national and international groups to monitor last Sunday’s elections. So it came as little surprise this week when unofficial observers and opposition political groups claimed the polls were again tainted with many of the same irregularities that plagued the 2008 elections.

The only group accredited to observe last weekend’s voting to elect 96 members of the two regional autonomous councils was the Center for Human, Citizen and Autonomous Rights (CEDHECA), whose regional leadership has known overlaps with Sandinista organizations. For example, Danilo Chang, the head of CEDHECA’s programs and projects department in Bluefields, the regional capital of the RAAS, is the same “Compañero Danilo Chang” who heads the Sandinistas’ Institute of Youth (INJUVE) in the RAAS.

Though no official winners had been announced by press time, preliminary tallies showed the Sandinistas poised to win in the RAAN and the Liberal Constitutional Party (PLC) to claim victory in the RAAS.

With 87 percent of the ballots counted, the Sandinistas had 43.8 percent in the RAAN, followed by 28.5 percent for the PLC and 13.9 percent for the indigenous party YATAMA.

In the RAAS, meanwhile, the PLC was leading with 37.4 percent of the vote, followed closely by the Sandinistas, with 34.5 percent. The Nicaraguan Liberal Alliance (ALN) was in third place, with 12.4 percent of the vote.

Still, it was unclear this week when – or if – the final results would be published by the CSE, which still hasn’t published the final results of the 2008 municipal poll.

“It’s still too early to say there has not been systematic fraud,” Courtney told The Nica Times, implying that the CSE has already lost the benefit of the doubt.

The PLC, which has been preemptively denouncing the elections as fraudulent since January, issued a list of concerns after the polls closed Sunday evening.

The opposition party alleged, among other things, instances of double voting, illegal voting by unregistered voters, ballots being tampered with before election day, and tabulated vote tallies being turned over to Sandinista activists instead of proper electoral authorities.

One of the more serious concerns raised was that the so-called “indelible ink” that all voters must dip their thumbs into after voting (to prevent double voting) was washing off people’s hands with a bit of soap and water.

Courtney claims the use of “faulty ink” was not a mistake, rather a ploy used in certain voting districts with a clear partisan preference to allow particular voters to cast multiple ballots.

Yet despite the loud concerns raised before, during and after the elections, the authorities of the embattled CSE have remained unfazed, as always.

In fact, just three days before the election, CSE president Roberto Rivas, who is under investigation in Costa Rica for corruption, and two other electoral magistrates were seen in a beach restaurant on Big Corn Island, slurping down lobster tails and polishing off an expensive bottle of Grand Old Parr Whisky during a long and woozy lunch break after dropping off ballots on the island.

The Sandinistas, who adamantly defend the job performance of Rivas and have proposed his reelection as head of the CSE, dismissed concerns of vote fraud this week. Sandinista lawmaker Edwin Castro said the opposition was just “crying wolf.”

Sandinista allies also remained quiet. Brooklyn Rivera, the head of the YATAMA group allied with the Sandinista Front, told The Nica Times this week that he thought last Sunday’s elections were “more orderly and transparent than the ’09 municipal elections” on the Caribbean coast, which were also denounced as fraudulent.

For Courtney, however, the numerous allegations and suspicions of fraud, coupled with one of the highest voter-abstention levels ever, are all symptoms of a dying electoral system.

Regardless of what the CSE pronounces in terms of winners and losers of last weekend’s vote, Courtney says it is abundantly clear that Nicaragua needs a new electoral system run by new authorities.

Returning to his plane metaphor, Courtney says “The current electoral system can’t deliver a safe landing.”

Trending Now

Costa Rica Approves Extradition of Ex-Minister Gamboa and Associates

A Costa Rican court has approved the extradition of former Security Minister Celso Gamboa Sánchez to the United States on charges of international cocaine...

Costa Rica’s Draw Against Honduras Boosts World Cup Hopes

Costa Rica held Honduras to a scoreless draw in their World Cup qualifier last night, picking up a point that keeps their qualification hopes...

Costa Rica Women’s National Team Coach Steps Down Amid World Cup Push

The Costa Rican Soccer Federation dropped a major update this week: Spanish coach Beni Rubido is stepping down from his role with the women's...

White House Calls Nobel Prize to Venezuelan Machado ‘Politics Over Peace’

The Norwegian Nobel Committee handed the 2025 Peace Prize to Venezuelan opposition leader María Corina Machado on Friday, sparking sharp words from the White...

Cost of living in Costa Rica from a U.S. Expat

Paradise doesn’t come cheap. Cars, gas, appliances, phones, TVs often cost more in Costa Rica. But not everything. Here’s a simple, like-for-like look at...

Costa Rican Hotels Warn of Job Risks Amid Drop in Tourists

Hotels across Costa Rica face mounting pressures as tourist numbers dip and a sluggish dollar exchange rate eats into their earnings. From January to...
Avatar
spot_img
Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Coffee Maker Chorreador
Costa Rica Travel Insurance
Costa Rica Rocking Chait
Costa Rica Travel

Latest News from Costa Rica